Fresh pizza, pasta, and more — made daily on Main Street and ready for carryout or delivery.
10% off your next online order
10% off
Use Coupon Code:
SAVE10
Real Tomato Pie. Real Goshen Tradition.
Real Tomato Pie. Real Goshen Tradition.
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie has been serving up neighborhood favorites right on Main Street in the heart of Goshen, NY. What started as a love for classic tomato pie has grown into a full menu of gourmet pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, jumbo buffalo wings, subs, and hoagies — made fresh daily using quality ingredients and time-tested recipes. Every pie is hand-stretched and topped with care, because we believe good pizza starts with doing the simple things right. It's the kind of food — and the kind of service — you can only get from a local, family-run kitchen that treats every customer like a regular.
Whether you're stopping in after a day at Good Time Park, grabbing a quick bite for the kids after school, or ordering a big spread for the whole family to enjoy at home, we're here to bring a little bit of comfort to your table. Our team takes pride in fast, friendly service, whether you're dining in, calling ahead for carryout, or ordering online for delivery right to your door. At Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie, we're not just making food — we're part of the community, one slice at a time.
Contact Form
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie is a pizza restaurant in Goshen offering takeout and delivery. The menu features a delicious variety of gourmet pizzas, authentic tomato pies, jumbo buffalo wings, pasta, subs, and hoagies made with fresh ingredients. Customers can enjoy a reliable neighborhood favorite located right on Main Street or order online for convenient takeout and delivery. Stop by to pick up your lunch or dinner today, or place your order online for easy delivery.
Cuisines
Pizza
Pasta
Calzones
Wings
Soup
Salads
Chicken
Seafood
Subs
Sandwiches
Wraps
Grill
Hoagies
Dessert
Italian
Hamburgers
Atmosphere
Casual Dining
Food Types
Healthy Options
Kids Menu
Service Options
Free Parking
Has TV
Outdoor Seating
Business Hours
| Mon - Sat: | 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM |
| Sun: | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
Carryout Hours
| Mon - Sat: | 10:00 AM - 9:40 PM |
| Sun: | 11:00 AM - 8:40 PM |
Delivery Hours
| Mon - Sat: | 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM |
| Sun: | 11:00 AM - 8:30 PM |
Tell Us About Your Experience!
★★★★★
My wife and I decided to grab a quick pizza. We found this little spot and the wings, pizza and services were top notch!
Alice B.
★★★★★
This spot is amazing! We came to Legoland in Goshen and saw a few flyers of quick eats in the lobby of the Fairfield Inns by Marriott. We ultimately settled on Goshen Pizza because the menu looked interesting. We are from Philadelphia and we heard about New Yorkers making some of the best pizza in the country. We ordered a personal size Boardwalk pizza, grilled chicken salad and a cannoli. Sounds plain, right? Well, we were shocked at how AMAZING it ALL tasted! Each order was delectable in its own right. The grilled chicken itself was perfection. The pizza tasted amazing the next day even after we took it from the fridge, so imagine how awesome it was when fresh! Do we have to mention the cannoli, which looked like it could have been one exotic sweet like you get in other countries? All in all, 10/10!
Ajay P.
★★★★★
Very good service. The foodbis excellent. I highly recommend this restaurant
Allen W.